Catholic Business Buddy

Catholic Business Buddy

Testing Your Ideas With Print on Demand

Gather data as you launch!

Kate Frantz @ Thy Olive Tree's avatar
Kate Frantz @ Thy Olive Tree
Dec 10, 2025
∙ Paid

Before I get to today’s article, I want to introduce you to Ann Aubrey. Ann loves to help Catholic authors and has this message to share with you all:

Allow ANN to replace AI.

Elevate your writing through human connection. Ann Aubrey offers editing expertise and book coaching for authors who want a personal touch! Her services include editorial analysis, mechanical editing, and substantive editing. You can get in touch with Ann at ann@annaubrey.com or via her website: www.annaubrey.com. She offers a 10% discount to paid members of this newsletter.


The above is a sponsored post and way for me to connect you with Catholic products and services. If you’d like to share a product or service that can help Catholic business owners, authors, or artisans, let me know: kate@thyolivetree.com.


Testing Your Ideas With Print on Demand (POD)

print on demand

When I launched my first book, I went all in. I spent thousands of dollars and several failed printing attempts at manufacturing a super complex book. (Don’t get me started on concealed wire-o book bindings 😅). Thankfully, it all worked out. People liked the book and I eventually sold all of them. But it was risky. I didn’t really have a proven concept. I didn’t know if there would be demand. And I had no idea how hard it would be to market my book. (Spoiler alert: It is hard!)

A faster, cheaper way to bring a new product to market, and a way to test your idea, is to print it on demand. I’ve written about print on demand (POD) before if you need a quick overview. It’s where you only have your items printed and shipped as someone places an order. No inventory or bulk orders needed. The best part about this is you can test many different products and designs at once to see which sell and which don’t.


I’ve moved off Substack. The best way to subscribe to stay in touch is by joining Thy Olive Tree’s Newsletter, below.

Sign Up Here


Using my book as an example, I could have published it to Amazon KDP for a few months to see how sales went. Was I selling enough to warrant a bulk order? Were the reviews positive? Was I getting feedback that something needed to change? I could gather all that data as I was making sales. THEN, I could have turned around and made a more informed decision about buying a small run of books.

This is even more helpful when it comes to products that are design-heavy. Will your customers want the design in blue, green, etc.? Sell them both on demand and see which one does best.

I’m doing this right now with my scarves and I can’t tell you how happy I am that I went this route. This is giving me time to test a new product and design idea. I don’t have 2,000 scarves in my basement. If this design tanks, I can try a new one, or pivot my business model entirely.

Just because you start with print on demand doesn’t mean you have to stick with it.

If you have a product that is selling really well, that might be your clue that it’s time to manufacture it in small runs. You can increase your profit margins and often create a higher quality product this way.

Since starting with print on demand, I have a few tips I’d like to share with you:

This post is for paid subscribers

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2026 Thy Olive Tree, LLC · Publisher Privacy ∙ Publisher Terms
Substack · Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start your SubstackGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture